In short: Seven verified luxury all-inclusive hotels in Rhodes, ranked on counted guest reviews and what each concept actually contains. Pick Mayia for adults-only calm at the top score, Amada Colossos for the most transparent Ultra terms, Eden Roc for the most generous inclusion — and note that Pegasos charges for its only à la carte.
Rhodes is one of Greece's biggest all-inclusive islands — and the terms vary wildly: from concepts including every à la carte restaurant weekly to hotels charging extra for their only à la carte venue. We verified the terms against the hotels' own sites and counted the guest reviews. Here are the seven luxury hotels that pass.
The figures against each hotel are counted from real guest reviews (Booking + Google) — never estimated. Unverifiable terms stay blank in the table.
How we ranked these hotels
The order rests on guest scores, the counted themes from our review analyses and what each concept actually contains — Amada's 'one dinner per restaurant per week' is a substantially more generous promise than Atlantica's 'one dinner per stay', despite matching scores. Under each hotel we explain its place.
Faliraki, Kolymbia or Kiotari — where should you stay?
Faliraki/Kallithea (Amada, Eden Roc, Mitsis, Pegasos) sits 15–20 minutes from both the airport and Rhodes Town — the most life, the longest beach. Kolymbia (Atlantica Imperial, Port Royal) is the east coast's calmer midpoint, about 25 kilometres from both the town and Lindos. Kiotari (Mayia) in the south rewards those wanting furthest from the crowds — allow a 50-minute transfer, but Lindos is closest of all.
We analysed the 267 most recently available guest reviews (Booking + Google) across the 7 hotels below — every figure is counted, never estimated. Reviews harvested August 2026. How we count mentions.
| # | Hotel | Concept | À la carte | Booking | Best for | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Mayia Exclusive Resort & Spa | Premium AI | 3, incl. with reservation | 9.4 | 4.8 | Adults wanting a beachfront resort with private Kiotari access |
| 2 | Amada Colossos Resort | Ultra AI (Gold) | 4, 1/rest. per week | 9.1 | 4.5 | Beach lovers wanting direct access to Kallithea Beach |
| 3 | Atlantica Imperial Resort | AI | 3, 1 dinner per stay | 9.1 | 4.8 | Adults wanting beachfront calm in Kolymbia |
| 4 | Port Royal Villas and Spa - Adults Only | AI (+Royal) | — | 9.1 | 4.7 | Couples wanting bungalows with private swim-up pools |
| 5 | Eden Roc Resort - All Inclusive | Premium AI | 4+, included | 8.5 | 4.5 | Families drawn to saltwater and waterslide pools |
| 6 | Mitsis Faliraki | Ultra AI 24h | 4, 1/rest. per week | 8.7 | 4.7 | Families wanting direct access to a sandy beach |
| 7 | Pegasos Beach | AI | 1, surcharge | 8.8 | 4.3 | Beach lovers wanting direct access to Faliraki beach |
1Rhodes, Greece
Food & restaurants: 60 of 60 mentions positive · Service & staff: 58 of 59 mentions positive
Mayia Exclusive Resort in Kiotari is the south coast's adults-only flagship (16+) — Premium All-Inclusive from 7am to 2am, with three à la carte restaurants included on reservation.
The highest score in the selection by a clear margin.
Why this rank: The highest score in the selection and a Premium concept with à la carte included — the adults-only profile in quiet Kiotari completes the package.
2Rhodes, Greece
Service & staff: 10 of 11 mentions positive · Pools, beach & aquapark: 6 of 6 mentions positive
Amada Colossos at Kallithea runs two Ultra tiers with unusual transparency: Gold grants one dinner per à la carte restaurant per week, Diamond unlimited.
'The smiliest staff ever' sums up our counted service mentions.
Why this rank: The tier system's transparency is the selection's best — one dinner per restaurant per week on Gold beats most rivals' terms.
3Rhodes, Greece
Service & staff: 14 of 15 mentions positive · Food & restaurants: 9 of 9 mentions positive
Atlantica Imperial in Kolymbia is the adults-only resort with manicured lawns and evening shows — 14 of 15 counted service mentions are positive, and upgrades are granted strikingly often.
Mind the concept's key fine print: a single à la carte dinner per stay.
Why this rank: Spotless service counts and manicured grounds — but a single included à la carte dinner per stay is thin for third.
4Rhodes, Greece
Pools, beach & aquapark: 20 of 20 mentions positive · Food & restaurants: 12 of 12 mentions positive
Port Royal Villas & Spa in Kolymbia is the adults-only beachfront — 20 of 20 counted pool and beach mentions are positive, 'the most comfortable sunbeds ever'.
The new Royal tier (2026) promises unlimited à la carte; the standard tier's visit caps are unpublished.
Why this rank: The pool and beach experience is the selection's best — unpublished standard terms and one serious management complaint in our count hold the position down.
5Rhodes, Greece
Service & staff: 15 of 15 mentions positive · Pools, beach & aquapark: 11 of 11 mentions positive
Eden Roc Resort at Kallithea is the family resort with the selection's most generous inclusion — the à la carte restaurants are included, and the concept even covers a prepaid dinner at a local meze taverna beyond the hotel.
All 15 counted service mentions are positive.
Why this rank: The selection's most generous inclusion and faultless service counts — a score a notch below the top settles fifth.
6Rhodes, Greece
Service & staff: 29 of 35 mentions positive · Food & restaurants: 28 of 35 mentions positive
Mitsis Faliraki is the round-the-clock concept: Ultra all-inclusive 24 hours, four à la carte restaurants each included once per week.
The Faliraki beachfront makes it the most accessible in the selection.
Why this rank: The 24-hour concept and transparent weekly terms convince — the score sits below the five above.
7Rhodes, Greece
Service & staff: 7 of 8 mentions positive · Location: 6 of 6 mentions positive
Pegasos Beach in Faliraki sits right on the sand with pools and kids' slides — but is also the selection's most honest warning: its only à la carte restaurant costs extra, and four counted value mentions judge the experience below a five-star standard.
Why this rank: The beachfront is excellent — but surcharged à la carte and four critical value mentions make last place honestly earned.
