Updated on April 24, 2023 by Axel Hernborg

Axel Hernborg

Affectionately known as the “conch” republic, Key West, Florida, has everything you could possibly dream of when it comes to finding the perfect resorts for your next holiday.

Of course, the most important thing about a resort holiday is that it comes with the tropical weather, which with Key West being in Florida, you can be sure that it has. 

There are a plethora of incredible resort properties for you to choose from when looking to stay in Key West, which makes choosing which one to stay at even more difficult.

Thankfully, we’ve put together this handy guide to help you decide which one is going to be right for you. 

As well as our guide to resorts, we’ll also provide you with a handy FAQ guide to Key West, which should help to resolve some of the most common questions people have about a vacation in the area. 

Without further ado, let’s get started!

Best Key West Resorts

Marker Key West Harbour Resort

When you mention luxury when staying in Key West, the Marker Key West Harbour Resort is always one of the first resorts that will pop up, and for good reason. 

This 4-star resort makes for an excellent choice of resort if you’re looking to holiday in the Conch Republic, and the combination of its incredibly enjoyable social activities program and the excellent dining options here has made it one of the places to stay in Key West. 

Thanks to being situated in the Northern section of Key West, this resort is in close vicinity to all of the top attractions and places of interest in the city, and is also a mere 10-minute stroll away from the popular sunset celebrations of Mallory Square. 

With amenities such as parking, three pools (one of which is adult only), and up to 96 different guest rooms for you to choose from for your stay here in Key West, then you can be sure that you’re going to find the right room for you. 

Overall, Markey Key West Harbour Resort makes for a more than excellent choice if you’re looking for an upmarket resort that is going to put you in a prime position to explore the local area to its fullest, so give it some thought before you pick a resort! 

Santa Maria Suites Resort

How many resorts have you been to where not only are you greeted by helpful and friendly staff upon arrival, but you’re also greeted with free ice cream too?

We’re not sure there’s many, which is why when you arrive at Santa Maria Suites Resort, and you’re greeted with free ice cream, you just know that your stay is going to be a special one. 

Thankfully, the perks and amenities don’t just end at complimentary ice cream, you are also provided with chilled towels next to the heated pool, bottled water, fresh fruit, and if they take your fancy, delicious smoothies too.

Daily treats are also made available to guests each day, with muffins in the mornings, and candies during the evening. 

With excellent concierge service and extremely helpful staff, then you can be sure that you’re going to be well taken care of throughout your stay in Key West. 

There’s also on-site dining, and the rooms are filled with all of the amenities you could need, including balconies or patios, HD TVs, full designer kitchens, en-suite bathrooms, and much more too. 

As you can tell then, this 4-star resort is definitely going to be one to consider when looking for the right resort for your perfect Key West holiday!

Pier House Resort & Spa

How does a resort with its very own private beach sound? Probably pretty good, right?

Well, if that’s got you interested, then you should definitely check out Pier House Resort & Spa, which not only includes access to the private beach, but also all of the amenities and features you need for a serene holiday in the sunshine. 

With a hot tub, heated waterside outdoor pool, as well as a full-service spa, Pier House has everything necessary for the relaxing break you need.

Plus, the on-site dining is excellent providing delicious Caribbean-influenced dishes as well as evening entertainment.

Another great aspect about Pier House is that because it is found at the end of the famous Duval Street, you’re well within walking distance of some of the most desirable attractions in the area, which means that you have full access to all of the best shopping and dining options within just a few minutes, allowing you to explore the area with ease. 

With 142 different suites that vary in size and budget, then there should be something for everyone at Pier House, which is exactly why it’s managed to make its way onto our list. 

Sunset Key Cottages

Looking for something more unique?

Then being on a 27-acre private island should definitely be something unique enough for you.

Just an eight minute boat ride away from Key West is Sunset Key Cottages, the perfect way to enjoy Key West’s natural beauty in complete serenity and peace. 

This location allows guests to pick from the standalone cottages on the island, with one to four bedrooms available, so whether you’re looking for a couples getaway, or to bring the whole family together, then Sunset Key Cottages should have you covered. 

The four-bedroom cottages are actually capable of sleeping nine people, and even have their own pools, with the ocean view providing the backdrop, as well as access to the private beach on the island, a private balcony, and even a jacuzzi. 

With a fitness centre, tennis courts, spa, and large outdoor swimming pool, we wouldn’t blame you if you didn’t leave the island at all.

There’s even a load of great activities to do on the water too, including fishing, kayaking, snorkelling, diving, and parasailing. 

If you’re looking for somewhere to eat, then look no further than the award winning Latitudes, a restaurant that will certainly make sure that you don’t go hungry! 

For those who really want to escape from it all (even if it is just 8 minutes away), then Sunset Key Cottages makes for a great choice. 

Hyatt Centric Key West Resort & Spa 

If you want to stay on a resort on Duval street without being amongst the action too much, then Hyatt Centric Key West Resort & Spa is going to be the place to stay, with this resort being situated towards the quieter Southern end of the street, which means that you can still explore the everything that Key West has to offer, just without all of the hustle and bustle. 

An on-site restaurant, private beach, hammocks, fitness centre, and even a concierge service are all available at this resort, which means that you can kick back and relax in style during your holiday. 

Even the standard rooms in this resort feature king-sized beds and furnished balconies, while the king suites provide you with a dining area, larger balconies, pull-out couches, and more spacious bathrooms too. 

If you need it, there’s an even bigger option in the form of the “Ocean View King Suite”, so you can be sure that Hyatt Centric has you covered! 

Opal Key Resort & Marina Key West

Newly refurbished and ready to be enjoyed, Opal Key Resort & Marina is close to Mallory Square and is also in close proximity to the cruise port of the city, so with over 170 spacious rooms, then it means that there is plenty of choice when it comes to staying here. 

All of the rooms are bright and well equipped, and the amenities in the resort will help you to relax throughout your stay, with a large swimming pool, full spa, and hot tub all being present. 

With parking and valet parking, as well as the ability to access Sunset Key Beach, then guests will thoroughly enjoy a stay here at Opal Key Resort and Marina! 

Final Thoughts

We hope you’ve enjoyed our guide to the most stunning resorts to be found in Key West. With the help of this guide, you should be able to find one that ensures that you have the perfect holiday! 

If you have any questions about staying in Key West, then check out our handy FAQ below, which should help answer the questions most people ask!

Frequently Asked Questions

Is Key West Expensive?

If you’re looking to try and stay in Key West on a budget, then you’re out of luck, as it’s one of the more expensive places to holiday in the U.S., especially due to its immense popularity. 

Is Key West Safe?

The average crime rate for Key West is in line with both the state and national average, so you should be perfectly safe during your time there.

TOP 10 BEST Beach Resorts & Hotels in  Florida Keys